Friday, May 27, 2005

Questioning Cliches

Questioning Cliches

I don't understand the phrase "I say jump, you say how high." Supposedly it's to signify the speaker's rank over the listener. But if the listener is asking questions in response to a command, isn't the listener mouthing off a bit? Stalling? Manipulating the speaker into a chance of getting out of jumping?

It seems to me the phrase should be "I say jump. You boing!"